Wednesday, September 10, 2014







Revolutions, Challenges, Effectiveness and Assessments in Online Learning-Module 4     According to Tennyson (2013), because 65% of higher education institutions consider their long-term strategy to include online courses, and because the business world also now provides training to their professionals, ensuring objectives in online learning is important. Online learning incorporates synchronous and asynchronous exchanges of information, use of Web 2.0 technologies such as blogs, podcasts, and wikis to facilitate learning, collaboration, and knowledge sharing. Social media can be used in MOOCs (massive open online courses) to change the learning landscape of higher education during the next decade (Tennyson, 2013). Measuring the success of these approaches is important.     Because I embrace a learner-based approach, I view online learning as an improvement in higher education. Although I support education on-demand, there are some concerns that need to be addressed. Tennyson (2013) has addressed various illegal activities and security threats causing the e-learning environment to be vulnerable. Some of the data that poses a security risk are loss of confidentiality and availability, breach of critical data, and vandalism of these learning management systems. Some educational institutions have acquired online learning management systems without addressing security aspects of online learning. Information and data could be accidentally or maliciously modified, destroyed, or stolen due to information manipulation by outsiders and/or insiders. This could affect the learner’s perception of a system’s reliability and trustworthiness (Tennyson, 2013), and this could affect the quality or accuracy of the answers given in an assessment. One can glean from this analysis that assessments and other learner submissions may be at risk of theft, alterations, and personal information being shared via a submission, which could then compromise the student’s personal well-being.
     Another consideration is student satisfaction. Web-based strategies are seen as a revolutionary progression because of flexibility and the ability to learn anywhere and at any time. This also costs the institution less than face-to-face classes (Chen & He, 2013). The overall academic satisfaction was measured between online and on-ground students utilizing a standardized student satisfaction survey and a method Chen and He (2013) called the ‘achievement of learning outcomes’ measurement tool. The online students performed better concerning self-directed, problem-based tasks, but rated themselves lower in perceived content mastery than students who attended in person, when in fact they performed just as well in both summative and formative assignments. Online learners reported more satisfaction with their learning experience than their campus-based counterparts (Chen & He, 2013).
     Web-based education offers endless opportunities for learners to observe and repeat the skills being taught utilizing methods that traditional teaching methods cannot. These include online discussion boards, which enhances the ability of students to experience complex levels of knowledge application in varied contexts. Student-led discussion boards allow students to accomplish the higher levels of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives (1956) through active debate. This taxonomy (a widely accepted framework within education) identifies six levels: knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation (Chen & He, 2013).     The summative assessment, intended to measure the sum total of knowledge, skills, and abilities acquired by the student in a unit or course, has been the assessment of choice for some time. Since the early 1990s, there has been a trend to incorporate formative assessments because they do not necessarily contribute to the student’s grade of the course, and may or may not be required. Instead, formative assessments provide useful practice and feedback throughout a course (Mackey, Derr & O’Connor, 2009).     If the issues of security were addressed, assessments could be designed to include a combination of discussions, periodic formative quizzes, and then a summative exam at the end of a particular period, and would include both multiple choice and short answer or essay questions.     Comparing the student participation between my on-ground to online class students, my experience has been that the online students engage more completely and immerse themselves in the content more thoroughly, possibly because they can choose to spend as much time as they desire, where on-ground classes only meet for a short, designated time. This semester, I have added a discussion component to one of my on-ground classes to see if I can simulate the online discussion experience. In another on-ground class, because of an E-book being provided that includes a new learning platform, I have also added formative quizzes as extra credit to test this approach to see if students benefit from this approach.
                                                         ReferencesChen, Y. & He, W. (2013). Security risks and protection in online learning: A 
                   survey. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,
                  14(5).
Mackey, T., Derr, D. & O’Connor, E. (2009). Cost-effective strategies for 
                  developing formative assessments in online workplace training. International
                 Journal of Advanced Corporate Learning, 2(4), 44-49. 
                 Doi:10.3991/ijac.v2i4.992Tennyson, M. (2013). Online or not? A comparison of students’ experiences of an
                  online and an on-campus class. Curationis, 36(1). Doi: 
                  10.4102/curationis.v36i1.73 

4 comments:

  1. Hi Christi,
    Really good work here! How might you apply this information to your doctoral research? Looking forward to hearing your ideas!
    Doc

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Dr. Courduff,
      thanks for your response. I am actually going to use this information in the online courses I teach. I will be adding the following components:
      • Make to-do lists for MCC
      • Make keyword lists for MCC
      • Title each module so students can learn the theme of the chapter.
      • Provide an index if necessary
      • Create a Q & A frequently asked questions discussion forum
      • Add audio component

      I will also use this information when I modify my financial literacy classes that I teach to a particular group of high school students who often have ADHD.

      Delete
  2. To Christi and all:

    “Massive Open Online Courses.” I have never heard of that! I think you might be right – this could become the wave of the future.

    I come in contact with the Vice-Principle of the town north of my place. His school district had to let go of nine teachers over the summer. Why? The student population is declining. The district might have to let two middle school teachers go next year also. I would think some sort of politics would play a factor in that though. The big question here is – where did/do all the students go? What Christi is alluding too is that students are getting education elsewhere. I noticed over the summer, an on online advertisement from Liberty, which announced an on-line high school academy. Hey – maybe more families are pursuing a home schooling option. This could really affect public school enrollment.

    Why would this be happening? It seems as though schools are in the media every day. When these institutions are in the news so often, it only portrays negative connotations. Parents have other options. Besides, with the recession the way it is, some parents are staying at home. So now they don’t have to worry about bullying, sex problems, peer pressures, or extra curricular activities that disjoint a family.

    Security! I never even thought about students stealing other student’s information – or hacking up their assignments. Online vandalism – that is what it is! The only purpose is to be malicious and mischievous. Teaching ethics and virtue needs to be incorporated more into schools K-C. A collateral duty of every teacher is to emphasize and model citizenship.

    I have always been a math/science type of a guy. Since I went back to college to get a degree in Elementary Education, I have a newfound fondness of Language Arts. Much like in mathematics, the more you practice, the better you get. To get good at reading and writing, we have to do it everyday – and not just for five or ten minutes. If one can read and write, then one can do just about everything. (Directions can be a wonderful thing!) So I like it when you indicate that students need to be able to express themselves. The good thing about online expression in education is that somebody is listening to you. Even if you are an introvert – somebody will read what you have written.

    Thank you for some different information Christi - Senior Chief

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Earl,
      Thanks for your comments. I think that online learning does, indeed, allow introverts to speak up. I also have observed that students in online classes share information they do not share in the on-ground classes. I have added a discussion forum to one of my on-ground classes to see if they like it.

      Your comment that if people can read and write, they can do just about anything makes so much sense. Sadly, I teach financial literacy classes to high school students who were marginalized when they were in lower grades, so they have poor reading skills. In some cases, English is a second language, and since Arizona only has English Immersion classes, these students drop out or do poorly in school.

      As for ethics and virtue, it seems to be evaporating before our eyes.

      Delete